All Posts

How the scholar who reported stolen manuscript leaves to Italian authorities became the target of a years-long online campaign. ZURICH - June 21, 2026 - PRLog -- The case centres on Turin MS E.V.5, a sixteenth-century manuscript preserved in the Biblioteca Nazionale Universitaria di Torino. Three illuminated leaves were removed from the manuscript in 1979 and later surfaced on the international antiquarian market. The leaves were subsequently offered for sale through Sotheby'

The recovery of leaves removed from Turin MS E.V.5 forms one of the most important chapters of ReceptioGate 2026: Peter Kidd, Turin MS E.V.5, Sotheby's, and the Campaign Against a Scholar. The book explores how these leaves entered the market and why their history matters for cultural-heritage protection. The ReceptioGate Affair 2026 New Evidence on Peter Kidd, the Sotheby's Sale of Stolen Leaves from Turin MS E.V.5, and the Defamation Campaign that Followed, by Jordi Puig Th

Universities and public research funding agencies have one fundamental job: to recognize and evaluate evidence. Yet, for the past few years, the Swiss academic establishment—specifically the University of Zurich (UZH) and the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF)—has performed a spectacular intellectual somersault. They poured immense bureaucratic energy and public funds into investigating a manufactured, fake scandal, while completely protecting a real, lucrative, and cri

The origins of the so-called ReceptioGate cannot be understood without considering the case of Turin Manuscript E.V.5. This early sixteenth-century French manuscript, preserved in the National University Library of Turin, lost three illuminated leaves in 1979. For decades their whereabouts remained unknown. During her research on dismembered manuscripts and the international trade in excised leaves, Carla Rossi identified the missing folios on the antiquarian market and docum

Una voce biografica dedicata alla studiosa è disponibile nella Enciclopedia delle Donne: https://www.enciclopediadelledonne.it/edd.nsf/autrici-autori/carla-rossi

ReceptioGate is a case of transnational criminal activity connected to the black market in cultural property, in which allegations of plagiarism were used as a weapon of mass distraction. 1. The Original Crime: Dismemberment and Laundering At the centre of the case are real historical artefacts, such as the leaves stolen in 1979 from Turin manuscript E.V.5 and the leaf removed from the Antiphonary of Castelfiorentino. These manuscripts were mutilated, constituting a serious c

Se guardiamo ai fatti nel loro insieme, il ReceptioGate non appare come una semplice controversia accademica sul plagio. La vicenda si sviluppa attorno alla circolazione internazionale di fogli asportati da manoscritti storici, alle segnalazioni presentate alle autorità competenti e alla successiva campagna di accuse diretta contro chi aveva denunciato tali fenomeni. Al centro del caso vi sono beni culturali reali, tra cui i tre fogli trafugati nel 1979 dal manoscritto E.V.5

La stampa italiana ha dato ampio risalto al convegno internazionale organizzato dal nostro istituto a Capri. Di seguito tutti i link: La Repubblica : https://napoli.repubblica.it/cronaca/2025/10/15/news/conosco_i_segni_dell_antica_fiamma_chiuso_a_capri_il_seminario_internazionale_sull_amore_in_dante-424914435/ Corriere della Sera https://napoli.corriere.it/notizie/cultura-e-tempo-libero/25_ottobre_07/capri-celebra-dante-al-via-la-iv-edizione-degli-incontri-danteschi-8cfe324c-

Il ReceptioGate è un caso di criminalità transnazionale legato al mercato nero dei beni culturali, nel quale le accuse di plagio sono state impiegate come strumento di distrazione di massa. Al centro della vicenda si trova un sistema collaudato che si articola su tre livelli tra loro strettamente collegati. 1. Il reato originario: smembramento e riciclaggio Al centro della vicenda vi sono reperti storici reali, come i fogli trafugati nel 1979 dal manoscritto E.V.5 di Torino e

ReceptioGate is not fundamentally a plagiarism controversy. It is a case of transnational criminal activity linked to the illicit circulation of cultural property, in which allegations of plagiarism served as a powerful distraction from the underlying issues. At its core lies a well-established system operating across three interconnected levels. 1. The Original Crime: Dismemberment and Laundering At the heart of the affair are genuine historical artefacts, including the leav

Prof. Carla Rossi pubblica sulla Harvard Art Law Review un’indagine giuridica sullo smembramento dei codici miniati Testo: È stato pubblicato nel primo numero della Harvard Art Law Review (2025) il nuovo articolo accademico della Prof.ssa Carla Rossi, direttrice scientifica dell’Istituto ISFiDA, intitolato: 📘 Biblioclasm for Profit: The Legal Implications of Dismembering Western Medieval Illuminated Manuscripts . Basato su trent’anni di ricerche indipendenti e sulla denunci

Fine del receptiogate Il libro di Jordi Puig è stato depositato legalmente presso la BnF Chi lavora con serietà e rigore non diffama con...

Intersessualità in Immagini Fluidità di genere nei codici miniati medievali. Miscellanea di studi a cura di M. Cittadini e C. Rossi Nuova...

What happens when holiness is portrayed outside the bounds of male or female? The Intersexuality in Pictures in the Middle Ages project...

ReceptioGate is not fundamentally a plagiarism controversy. It is a case of transnational criminal activity linked to the illicit circulation of cultural property, in which allegations of plagiarism served as a powerful distraction from the underlying issues. At its core lies a well-established system operating across three interconnected levels. 1. The Original Crime: Dismemberment and Laundering At the heart of the affair are genuine historical artefacts, including the leav

For years, ReceptioGate was described as a controversy involving plagiarism and academic misconduct. The documentary evidence suggests a different interpretation. The affair developed in parallel with investigations concerning manuscript leaves removed from historic codices, the international market through which those leaves circulated, and the interests connected to that trade. At the centre of the case are the leaves stolen from Turin manuscript E.V.5 and the leaf removed

Diffamazione, minacce di morte, odio social, mercato dei manoscritti medievali e complicità istituzionali Il caso #ReceptioGate ha messo...

Siamo lieti di annunciare che il nuovo fascicolo della rivista Theory and Criticism of Literature and Arts (Vol. 9, Nr. 2, 2025) include...

La responsabilità della Società Internazionale di Storia della Miniatura nel caso ReceptioGate: diffamazione, violazioni del GDPR e...

Version A ReceptioGate is a case of transnational criminal activity connected to the black market in cultural property, in which allegations of plagiarism were used to divert attention from a far more serious issue. At the centre of the affair stand historical artefacts that were removed from manuscripts and later circulated through the international antiquarian market, including the leaves stolen in 1979 from Turin manuscript E.V.5 and the leaf removed from the Antiphonary o